Here is a summary I once compiled for lecture notes regarding SPICE integration methods:
• TRAP and GEAR are the most heavily used integration methods in circuit simulation.
• For a fixed time-step ∆T, the most accurate method is TRAP, followed by GEAR.
• TRAP is overly sensitive to errors of previous time steps, so not to be used when RELTOL is loose!
• For abrupt signal changes, BE (backward Euler = GEAR order 1) and TRAP adapt fast, so they can provide an advantage, but one needs to be aware of the ringing introduced by TRAP.
• GEAR2 is efficient for simulating with tight tolerances or smooth waveforms.
• BE, TRAP, and GEAR2 are stable on stiff circuits (i.e. don’t show ringing) but BE shows strong artificial numerical damping (TRAP shows no damping, GEAR2 weak damping).
• Overall, GEAR2 seems to be preferred by most circuit designers.
Set the GEARx order by
.options *MAXORD=x*